Ch. 6 Case Study Analysis
Post your responses to the following questions on your blog.
Case 1: Mr. West wants his students to truly understand Civil War battles. He engages the help of a local Historical Re-enactment Society and assigns each of his students to the Union or Confederate side. His students join the re-enactors from 7:00am-7:00pm for a full day of activities which include a long march (complete with rudimentary battle gear), setting up camp, cooking over campfires, scouting territory, and engaging in a historically representative battle.
1. After participating in this activity, what do you think the students will remember? How might those memories differ from those students would have if they only read about the Civil War in their textbook?
The Students will remember if it was cold, how long the walk was, what the food tasted like, the stories the other re-enacters would tell.The students would be able to explain what a battle would be like, the feelings, the people, the unknown.
If a student would have to tell you about the battle from just a book they probably would only remember one or two big things because they were not there to experience them.
2. How does Mr. West’s use of a Civil War re-enactment engage students’ emotions? What is the relationship between emotions and learning?
Mr. West uses the Civil War re-enactment to engage students emotions by letting them feel what it was like to be a soldier. He puts them in the activity and lets them feel what it was like. The sorrow, loss, pain, cold, hunger. All of those things adding into how it really was. By having these emotions and connecting it with what they learned the students are able to recall it easier and remember it longer. Whenever they feel that emotion again they will think about the things they learned. The relationship between emotions and learning are that they leave longer lasting impressions because of the connections in the brain that are made.
3. Based on the principles of dual-coding theory, what activities would be effective for Mr. West to use as a follow-up to the re-enactment?
A good way for Mr. West to follow-up the re-enactment would to have the students watch a video clip of what they experienced, maybe even a home video of the students re-enacting it. Then once they watched the video they could discuss what they learned, what it would have been like when it happened, what happened. By doing this the students will recall the information and have some critical thinking.
Case 2: Mr. Dunkin and Mr. Richards, teachers at the same school, are debating in the teacher’s lounge about who provides the best type of organization for the students’ learning. Mr. Dunkin lectures and assigns reading and chapter problems Mondays through Thursdays. On Fridays he gives a short answer exam. In Mr. Richards’ class the students never know what will take place on any given day until they arrive in class and look at a detailed outline of the hour’s activities on the chalkboard. His class engages in mix of role-plays, lecture, videos, group projects and demonstrations. Mr. Richards occasionally gives surprise quizzes and his unit tests can include true/false, multiple choice, short answer, or essay.
4. Who do you think provides better instruction for his students? Support your answer from an information processing perspective.
I believe that Mr. Richards is teaching with the best type of organization because he is able to teach to every kind of multiple intelligence. He also teaches in so many ways that the experiences become memorable to the students, and not just repetition of information. The more he hits a subject, in different ways, the more connections the students will make, and will be able to remember.
5. How would you expect the students’ learning outcomes to differ depending on which teacher they had?
If I was the student, then I would not be able to learn effectively from Mr. Dunkin. I like hands on activities as well as different learning methods. It's hard for me to just listen to a lecture, read the book and do a worksheet. I need the different experiences. However, other students like the formatted way Mr. Dunkin teaches. It all depends on what Multiple Intelligence you learn best by.